Winning a paypal 'non-receipt claim' dispute?

[chinko14]

Information about the dispute can be found here http://www.epicnpc.com/threads/701278-Archeage-Gold-Scammer-turkletont but to sum it up:

>2 weeks ago sold gold for $190. Friendly guy, transaction went well.
>Few days later - paypal email saying that he filed a dispute
>Said he bought an Xbox One off me and I didn't deliver and cut off all communication
>I escalated to a claim, thought I would win because I showed pictures showing it was a intangible transaction and most certainly not for an xbox
>I lost the claim
>Call up paypal
>this guy gave them a URL of a fake xbox one auction wtf
>appeal the claim
>heavy stalking and tracing
>found his name, address, phone number, and IGN of main archeage character
>called his house from New Zealand
>guy isn't home
>this guy told his mom he won a dispute over an xbox one wtf
>submitted a crapton of evidence to paypal for now

Sorry for the crap formatting, but putting it into paragraphs would take way too long.
I was just wondering if anyone has had experience with these kinds of claims and could give any advice on what to submit or do?
I can't elaborate on how I found all his personal info or what I submitted to paypal because he might be reading this.
What I can say that it is basically conclusive evidence if the paypal investigator actually reads the 6000 words with the URLs.

 

[The Integrity]

Paypal dispute resolution is random.
Regardless of how hard your evidence are, the guy who lied in his 2 sentences has equal chances of winning.

 

[chinko14]

Thanks for the reply. Yeah I was pretty surprised that I lost the first time but I guess it makes sense if he actually gave a link to an auction.
Managed to get the dispute re-opened so that's a start. Guess we'll see where it goes from there.

 

[doubleyou]

Banned - Paypal payment reversed

I was scammed for $10 USD which I sent for an account. Because I'm new to paypal how do I go about disputing? Because I did the transaction as family or friends can isa till dispute?

 

[leanardo]

Yes paypal is pretty bad when it comes to disputes, I had a paypal person tell me if you pay with your credit card it best to do a fraud instead of a bad deal, paypal hates virtual items and it is not covered at all, anything can be recalled no matter what the evidence is. they would rather side with the person saying it is fraud, because they will not fight a credit card company at all.

 

[chinko14]

I was scammed for $10 USD which I sent for an account. Because I'm new to paypal how do I go about disputing? Because I did the transaction as family or friends can isa till dispute?

Yea honestly in this case I don't really think you can't dispute anything on either end. As soon as they see that it's for intangibles the case is pretty much thrown out the window