Inappropriate negative feedback by isi92

[WHINKERTON.COM]

Information
######################
Date that sale/trade took place: 21/11/2013
Method of Contact Used: Skype
Instant Messenger ID of other party: isti920817
Your Instant Messenger ID: whinkerton

Sale/Trade Information
######################
This user wanted to trade 100k of WoW Gold, but instead of that he gave me only 50k for which he got paid(!) Unforutantely he wanted also to get paid for the part of gold which he didn't give me... and now because of that he gives me negative feedback. He claims that he traded 100k instead of 50k, but he doesn't want to prove that he traded more than 50k, no screenshots etc. When we were trading I gave him clear instructions how to trade + I wrote in capitalics that screenshots are very important in this trade(that's always the info I give to my customers, to take screenshots just in case, to preven situation like this one ):

I also paid him for the 50k which he delivered to me, but after that he issued a refund.

Link of transaction thread: http://www.epicnpc.com/threads/528675-BUYING-WoW-EU-US-GOLD-FOR-MONEY-HIGHEST-RATE-FAST-PAYMENT-TRUSTED!!!
Approximate value of property: $20-70 USD

Was a middleman used?: no

Describe why you believe the feedback is wrong: please look above
Other details / notes: this guy was very impatient when we were trading

Proof
######################
Situation is explained above + screenshot of payment

Additional Information
######################
Did you do any background searching before the trade?: no
Have you traded with this person before?: no
I would like to only mention that I'm user who cares about the reputation, so far there were no negative feedbacks for me and also I do my best so the customer and I are happy, I didn't scamm that guy and you have proofs, please check this user and judge wheter the feedback should be deleted or not.

 

[EpicNPC]

isi92 has been notified.

What is the Paypal refund? You paid him $20 for 50k gold, then refunded him?

 

[WHINKERTON.COM]

isi92 has been notified.

What is the Paypal refund? You paid him $20 for 50k gold, then refunded him?

No, I paid him

I also paid him for the 50k which he delivered to me, but after that he issued a refund.

After I paid him for 50k which he delivered to me, he sent the money back, that's rather irrelevant to the issue.(I didn't say to refund the money, he did it on his own and doesn't want to get paid for those 50k... and blames me of stealing 100k... that guys is very hard to understand what he wants, sorr to say that but it's rather obvious that he tries to scamm for payment of 100k which he didn't deliver)

 

[EpicNPC]

Whinkerton buys 100k gold from isi92
isi92 delievers 50k
Whinkerton pays $20 because only half was delivered
isi92 claims 100k gold was delivered
isi92 refunds $20

Did you give him back the 50k gold? Why did he refund you?

I don't understand this dispute at all. waiting for isi92 to reply, but I already removed the feedback as I don't think he will. Normally I wouldn't remove it until you proved you only got 50k, but since he refunded you I'll take that as something strange is going on, so isi92 will have to prove his claim instead.

Closing in 48 hrs if he doesn't reply.

 

[WHINKERTON.COM]

Correct, I received 50k, I paid for it, but after that he refunded the money (he didn't want neither the money nor the gold back), after that he claims that he gave me 100k and gives me negative feedback and deletes me from Skype, strange guy and situation. Most important is that I strongly recommended to take screenshots and he doesn't want to prove any to show that he traded more.

Thank you very much for your dedications to this case and reaction.

Best Regards,
Whinkerton

 

[EpicNPC]

isi92 was online yesterday and didn't bother posting. Closing.