EpicNPC

Register a free account today to become a member!

False Feedback and Harassment

Not Recently Bumped
Status
Not open for further replies.

oneilsurfing

Level 31

Trade Guardian Orders: 4

(100%) (2 reviews)
Country
United States
Member Since
Feb 23, 2008
Country
United States
Multiple Accounts
0
Please link to the feedback and explain why it should be removed or edited.

https://www.epicnpc.com/feedback/feedback/805958/view

https://www.epicnpc.com/threads/sel...mane-us-fake-name-mc-bwl-ony-attuned.2621551/ -thread where he is spamming as well.

First of all, he is putting the name on the account out in the open, both on the feedback and repeatedly on my posts, despite having admins removing it multiple times. This clearly puts the account in danger of being banned or having security issues. I don't understand how this isn't an instant ban.

Second, he asserts that I am unfriendly, unprofessional and hateful, which, assuming you can review our chat and the subsequent trade guardian interactions, you can see that I was friendly despite having deal with him consistently not being around when he said he would to complete the transaction. He even left me a 5 star review originally, until I left an honest review to beware trading with him, due to his unreliability and wasting of people's time. Another person reported him for the same exact issue right after.

Third, the entire reason for his backing out of the trade guardian in the first place, was because he did not believe that "Jim Jimmison" was a fake name. First of all, if you speak any english, this is clearly a 100% fake name. The Middleman agreed. However, I realize this is subjective, so I offered to share my ID with the Middleman so that he could confirm my name is indeed not Jim Jimmison. This on top of the fact that my paypal account his my name on it, and he could see it there. I think he was just looking for an excuse to back out.

In the end, this person changed their review in retaliation for my honest feedback, in order to insinuate dishonesty on my part, which they could not prove, and I offered to disprove during the Trade Guardian process. They are unstable and vengeful, and have spammed negative comments, ,multiple times on the same post. This again, includes the account name. And despite having their posts removed via report, they spammed more.


All of this, and the sale never even took place. Because they backed out.
 
The name has been removed from the feedback. The term "hateful" has been removed as I saw nothing hateful posted in the chat.

Both feedback were changed to neutral as they are 100% opinion base. You can't prove the name is fake and we can't confirm it's fake either. Googling the name, there are plenty of people with that name.
 
I offered to provide my ID for the middleman to confirm, it is indeed not my name. I guess you are right, 3 people in their 80s show up on a google search. Nevermind that this "buyer" has negative feedback for doing similar shady things (https://www.epicnpc.com/feedback/feedback/805829/view), a Trade with Caution warning, and changed their review to negative only after I posted a negative review (clearly retaliation, not proof).

As I am reading these forums I see that both of our feedback should be remove, as no sale actually took place? The only reason payment received was ever selected on the transaction was to allow the middleman to retain the fee. I still think mine should stand, since this "buyer" wasted a massive amount of my time, requesting extra work done to the account, promising to be around to transact and not showing up or messaging, as well as my clearly stated offer in the TG process to provide my ID to the MM to prove the name was fake (an offer that stands to resolve this process). However, I can live with both reviews being removed if it means an invalid feedback on me is gone.

That being said, I would like to know what assurances I have that he will not continue to post in an unhinged manner on my account selling post? He has posted 6 times, all similar things with false accusations that I am the time waster, most of which have thankfully been removed. I dont understand how posting the name on account you learned during the trade guardian that you backed out of isnt a bannable offense in the first place. And lastly, his messages, even with with the name removed, are accusing me of selling an account with my own name on them, something he can not prove, and something I have *repeatedly*, including during the TG process, offered to disprove. Sorry to be difficult, but I really dont feel like dealing with a an unhinged guy with multiple instances of bad transactions and a trade with caution (something I admittedly should have heeded) banner on his account, spamming every single one of my posts. Thank you.
1696783354666.png

1696783326993.png
 
Last edited:
Feedback is allowed once something was exchanged, either payment or account/item. In this case the account was transferred to the MM, then it was cancelled, so feedback is allowed to be exchanged.

We do not review opinion based feedback such as "unfriendly". The feedback was already edited and unfounded claims were removed. That's all we can do. Sorry.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top